The Essential Role of Design Documents. What are they?

Design documents play a crucial role in the software development process. They serve as a blueprint for proposed systems, allowing teams to explore alternatives, understand the rationale behind design decisions, and collaborate effectively. In this article, we’ll delve into the key aspects of design documents and their significance. 📝✨

What Are Design Documents? 📄

Design documents are comprehensive written descriptions of a proposed system, feature, or component. They provide a detailed account of how a system should be built, including its architecture, functionality, and interactions. Design docs serve as a bridge between high-level requirements and actual implementation.

Photo by Miguel Luis on Unsplash

Purpose and Benefits 🌟

1. Sharing Alternatives: Design docs facilitate discussions by presenting multiple design alternatives. Teams can evaluate trade-offs and choose the most suitable approach. 🔄

2. Understanding Complexity: A well-structured design doc helps developers, testers, and other stakeholders comprehend the system’s intricacies. It clarifies the “why” behind design decisions. 🤔

3. Maintainability: Even after a system is implemented, design docs remain valuable. They serve as documentation for future maintainers, aiding in troubleshooting and enhancements. 🛠️

Content to Include in a Design Document 📝

When creating a design document, consider the following components:

1. Summary: Begin with a concise overview of the proposed system. Highlight its purpose, scope, and key features. 📋

2. Motivation: Explain why this system is necessary. What problem does it solve? What benefits will it bring? 💡

3. Screenshots/Images: Visual aids provide a quick understanding of the feature. Include relevant screenshots or diagrams. 🖼️

Photo by Christina @ wocintechchat.com on Unsplash

1. Preferred Choice: State your preferred design approach. Justify why it’s the best option. ✔️

2. Design Alternatives:
   • Present alternative designs. Discuss their pros and cons.
   • Consider factors like performance, scalability, maintainability, and user experience. 🔄
3. Other Considerations:
   • Mention any experiments or prototypes you’ve conducted.
   • Provide references to related research or existing solutions. 🧪🔍
4. Post-Launch Evaluation:
   • After the system is deployed, revisit the design choices.
   • Explain which design was implemented and share results (e.g., performance metrics, user feedback). 🚀📊

Remember, design docs are living documents. Update them as needed during the development lifecycle. By fostering collaboration and informed decision-making, they contribute to successful software projects. 🚀

The Benefits of Design Documents 🌟

Design documents play a pivotal role in software development, fostering collaboration, informed decision-making, and efficient project execution. Let’s explore the numerous advantages they offer:

Photo by Victor on Unsplash

Immediate Impact on Implementation 💡

1. Solidifying Ideas: An idea remains abstract until it’s written down. Design docs transform concepts into tangible plans. They also help you stay on track during implementation. 📝

2. Collaborative Design: Design docs allow multiple stakeholders to contribute to the design process and understand what is being implemented. By involving various team members, you can collectively flush out a robust design. Diverse perspectives lead to better solutions. 🤝

3. Optimal Design Choices: Imagine coding an entire project only to discover that there’s a better way to implement it. Design docs prevent such scenarios. By thoroughly evaluating alternatives upfront, you ensure that the best design is chosen from the outset. ✅

4. Efficient Communication: Rather than repeatedly explaining how a system works, direct colleagues and curious team members to the design doc. It saves you time and ensures consistent messaging. 📣

5. Shareability and Acceleration: A well-documented design can be shared with others, accelerating project adoption. It becomes a reference point for discussions and knowledge transfer. 📚⚡

6. Code Review Clarity: Approvers of your code can refer to the design doc to understand the context. It streamlines the review process and reduces ambiguity. 📝👀

7. Alignment and Dispute Resolution: When disagreements arise during implementation, the design doc serves as a reference point. If someone deviates from the agreed-upon design, you can point to the doc and maintain alignment. 📄🤝

Future-Proofing and Beyond 🚀

1. Documentation for the Future: Without a design doc, future maintainers might struggle to understand why certain decisions were made. The doc consolidates choices, making it easier for them to grasp the system’s intent. 📖

2. Summarizing Accomplishments: Managers and stakeholders often need a high-level understanding of progress. Design docs create a narrative. For instance, if you’ve fixed ten bugs, the doc can highlight their impact and the overall project trajectory. 📊

In summary, design docs are more than just paperwork—they’re essential tools for successful software development. So next time you embark on a project, consider creating a thoughtful design doc. 📝✨

When You Don’t Need a Design Document ❌

While design documents are valuable, there are scenarios where they might not be necessary. Let’s explore when you can skip creating a formal design doc:

Photo by Aron Visuals on Unsplash

1. Straightforward Implementations: For simple tasks like updating the appearance of a button, fixing a minor bug, or adding a new layout to a view, a full-fledged design document may be overkill. These straightforward changes can often be handled without extensive documentation. 🎯

2. Lack of Complexity: If the task lacks complexity or doesn’t involve critical architectural decisions, a brief explanation in a GitHub issue or work item might suffice. Sometimes, a concise description of what you did is more efficient than a lengthy design doc. 📄

3. Minimal Additional Value: When creating a design document won’t significantly enhance understanding or decision-making, consider whether the effort is justified. If the task is self-explanatory or doesn’t impact the overall system significantly, an elaborate design doc may be unnecessary and time-consuming. ⏳

4. Stakeholder Interest: No one is particularly invested in or will ever care to understand the intricate details of what is being done. An example is a bug fix. Stakeholders are primarily concerned with getting it resolved quickly and about the impact. 🐞

Remember, the goal is to strike a balance. While design docs enhance communication and decision-making, adapt their use based on the context and the specific needs of your project. 🚀

Choosing the Right Platform for Design Documents 🖥️

When it comes to writing design documents, selecting the appropriate platform is crucial. My preferred choice for creating design documentation is using a Git Documentation Repository. But, let’s explore the pros and cons of different options, including considerations related to handling images:

1. Google Docs or Microsoft Word:

Photo by Ed Hardie on Unsplash

Pros:

• Familiarity: Many people are comfortable using these tools.
• Collaboration: Real-time collaboration allows multiple team members to work on the same document simultaneously.
• Formatting: Robust formatting options are available.
• Shareability: Google Docs and Microsoft Word documents are easily shareable with both technical and non-technical stakeholders. They provide a polished and presentable format. 📎

Cons:

• Lack of System Tracking: While these tools are great for content creation, they lack built-in tracking mechanisms. There’s no inherent system to manage tasks, approvals, or changes.
• Version Control: Managing different versions can be challenging.
• Communication Overhead: Long threads and replies can clutter the document, making it harder to follow discussions. 📉

1. Git Documentation Repositories (e.g., GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket):

Photo by Roman Synkevych on Unsplash

Pros:

• Version Control: Design documents stored in repositories benefit from version control. Each change is tracked, and you can easily compare revisions.
• Pull Request Workflow: Treat your design document like a pull request. It requires approval, and stakeholders receive notifications. This visibility ensures accountability.
• Structured Organization: Create a dedicated folder within your repository for design-related files. Keep everything organized.
• Integration with Codebase: Having design docs alongside the codebase fosters a holistic understanding of the system.
• Markdown Format: Markdown files can be converted into static documentation websites, making it easier to create official project documentation.
• Searchability: Markdown files allow you to search for content across several files. 🔍

Cons:

• Learning Curve: Some team members might be less familiar with Git workflows.
• Storage Overhead: Large binary files (such as high-resolution images) can bloat the repository size. This affects cloning, fetching, and storage costs.
• Git History: Over time, the repository history accumulates, potentially making it unwieldy. Purging history (e.g., using git filter-branch) can help, but it’s not always straightforward. 📈

Remember that the choice of platform depends on your team’s preferences, collaboration needs, and existing workflows. Whether you prioritize version control, ease of insertion, collaboration features, or shareability, ensure that your design documents effectively convey information and facilitate decision-making. 📝✨

References

In crafting this article, I’ve drawn insights from:

1. My Personal Experience:
   • Drawing from my own startup journey working on CaughtUp LLC and my work as a software engineer for several projects, I’ve learned the importance of effective design documentation. Real-world experiences often provide valuable insights.
2. Clément Mihailescu - What Is A Design Doc In Software Engineering? (full example):
   • Clément Mihailescu, a former Google software engineer, provides an in-depth explanation of what design documents are and how they impact the development process. His video includes a practical example, making it a great resource for understanding the concept. Watch the video
3. TechLead - What is a Design Doc: Software Engineering Best Practice #1:
   • TechLead (Patrick Shyu), a former tech lead at Google and Facebook, shares insights into design documents as a best practice in software engineering. His video covers the significance of design docs and their role in building robust systems. Watch the video

Feel free to explore these references to deepen your understanding of design documents and enhance your software development practices. 📚✨

Journal

• 2020-08-14 Initial notes
• 2020-12-20 Created file
• 2021-03-09 Updated Styling
• 2024-05-09 Updated article to make it read better